Spell
NormalMayakashi Return
Archetype:
Mayakashi
View:
4117
Take 1 "Mayakashi" card from your Deck, except "Mayakashi Return", and either add it to your hand or send it to the GY. You can only activate 1 "Mayakashi Return" per turn.
Mayakashi Return — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 64 ± 6 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 63 · Deck: 69 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Searcher / Tutor · Secondary: Combo enabler, Utility
Why it scores here
Mayakashi Return is a core tutor for one of the game's most focused mill-based archetypes, featuring 100% inclusion in pure Mayakashi and Mayakashi Shiranui builds at 2–3 copies. Its strength lies in reliable accessibility and clean archetype synergy: tutoring any Mayakashi monster to hand or the graveyard supplies both consistency and GY-setup value essential to the archetype's recursive game plan. However, it earns no score from material utility (being a spell card), lacks any opponent-facing interaction, and its once-per-turn restriction limits raw explosive potential. Power is purely in tutoring reliability and archetype fit, not in creating large independent value swings.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 92 | 100% inclusion in Mayakashi and Mayakashi Shiranui with 2–3 copies typical; activates as a spell card with no special conditions. (verified) |
| Combo & Conversion | 65 | Tutor and mill effects enable Mayakashi synergies and further plays, but no combo boards are supplied to assess actual board depth and endstate value. (inferred) |
| Resource Economy | 60 | Tutor provides zero card advantage; real value derives from tutoring the optimal Mayakashi piece at the right moment or milling for GY synergy. (verified) |
| Effect & Interaction | 5 | Mayakashi Return has no negation, removal, or opponent-facing interaction; it is purely a tutoring and milling effect. (verified) |
| Material Utility | 0 | As a Spell Card, Mayakashi Return cannot serve as material for Synchro, Xyz, Link, or Fusion summons and carries zero material utility. (verified) |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 70 | Once-per-turn activation limits raw utility, but instant spell resolution avoids field presence and the choice between hand and GY tutoring provides flexibility based on game state. (verified) |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 72 | 100% inclusion in Mayakashi-specific archetypes at 2–3 copies, but nearly absent in non-Mayakashi decks, indicating strong archetype dependency and tight deckbuilding constraints. (observed) |
Calculation
Weight profile: Primary: Searcher / Tutor. Intrinsic ≈ 63, Deck ≈ 69, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: Archetype-locked specialization (-2); Combo data gap penalty (-1); Exceptional redundancy and consistency (1). Final formula: 0.40 * Intrinsic + 0.60 * Deck
Strengths
- Perfect fit in Mayakashi and Mayakashi Shiranui with 100% inclusion rates
- Clean tutor effect with choice of hand or graveyard destination, enabling both consistency and mill synergy
- High redundancy (2–3 copies typical) ensures backup options and strong draw quality in the archetype
- Clear, straightforward text with no complex timing or ruling interactions
- Strong synergy with core Mayakashi monsters and recursive graveyard strategies
Weaknesses
- Spell-locked archetype searcher with no material utility when effect is negated or if graveyard strategies fail
- Once-per-turn restriction prevents explosive multi-card tutoring on a single turn
- Zero opponent-facing interaction or disruption capability
- Highly archetype-specific; nearly unusable outside Mayakashi/Shiranui builds (garnet risk in non-focused decks)
- Provides only +0 card advantage and relies entirely on graveyard synergy value to justify inclusion cost
Counters / choke points
- Effect negation (Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring, Effect Veiler) prevents the tutor but allows the card to remain in hand
- Deck shuffle effects (Droll & Lock Bird) can stop the tutor by disrupting the Deck itself
- Spell negation (Solemn Judgment, Crossout Designator) prevents the tutor entirely
- Graveyard disruption (Dimensional Fissure, Macro Cosmos) nullifies the milling value and forces hand-only play
Best use
Core tutor enabling consistency and graveyard setup. Decks: Mayakashi, Mayakashi Shiranui, Shiranui. Suggested copies: 3.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Card text: Tutors 1 Mayakashi card from deck to hand or GY; once-per-turn limit.; 100% inclusion in Mayakashi and Mayakashi Shiranui decks (151/161 + 50/50 = 100% of core archetypes).; Average 2.88 copies per deck; 88.7% of decks (356/400) run the maximum 3 copies.; Legal in TCG, OCG, MasterDuel, DuelLinks with no banlist token (assumed unlimited).; Zero material utility (Spell Card cannot be used as Synchro/Xyz/Link/Fusion material).; Zero opponent-facing interaction (no negation, removal, or disruption effects).
- Observed: Appears across 25 distinct archetypes in the sample, but 62.7% of decks (251/400) are pure Mayakashi variants.; Top 10 co-deck partners are all Mayakashi core monsters (Yuki-Onna, Mezuki, Yuki-Musume, Yoko, Dakki, Hajun, Tsuchigumo, Gashadokuro, Oboro-Guruma, Tengu).; 80.8% co-deck rate with One for One (323 decks), indicating synergy with Foolish Burial and other mill enablers.; Listed in Core sections of three Mayakashi guides (official, Legend Anthology, general).; Present in minor splashes in Eldlich (2.2%), Vampires (2%), Kashtira (1.8%), and others; inclusion drops to <2% outside Mayakashi/Shiranui variants.; 100% inclusion in Mayakashi Shiranui variant (50/50 decks) with typical 3 copies, confirming strong hybrid synergy.
- Inferred: Tutor effect enables both consistency (hand tutoring) and archetype synergy (GY milling for recursion-based strategies).; Choice between hand and GY destination provides tactical flexibility; GY option directly supports Mayakashi's recursive and mill-focused game plan.; High copy count (2–3 typical) and strong partner synergy suggest this is a consistency card, not a value engine; power derives from reliable access to key pieces.; Archetype-locked design: text restricts tutoring to Mayakashi cards, limiting portability to non-Mayakashi decks and creating garnet risk outside focused builds.; Once-per-turn restriction prevents explosive tutoring sequences and limits raw play-line flexibility on a single turn.
- Data gaps: No combo boards supplied (0 appearances in combo data); combo conversion is entirely text-based inference and cannot be verified against recorded synergy patterns. No banlist token provided; assumed unlimited (3 copies legal in all formats). No Top Card rankings or competitive tournament data; card is not ranked in the top-card context. No rulings conflicts or edge-case interactions documented; assumes clean once-per-turn timing. Limited guide coverage (3 guides) vs. 400 deck samples; guide detail on optimal tutoring lines unavailable.






